Writers logo

How Justin @Vocal RUINED my Entire Story

Solving conspiracy theories before the story is posted. Sound suspicious?

By Criminal MattersPublished 11 days ago Updated 8 days ago 3 min read
Top Story - March 2026

I debated whether I should write this.

I was bored, so I wrote it.

Then I argued with myself about posting it.

Yes, I did answer myself.

Annnnd, here I am.

I know the title sounds like I’m upset or about to unleash a Burger King whopper-style rage.

But, no, that isn’t why I’m here.

I do, however, need to have a little talkie talk with the one and only Justin.

Yep, that Justin, the Vocal MAN.

He (unintentionally) ruined my story.

I'm not saying I'm mad. I'm just...disappointed.

He’s not in trouble. Too much trouble, I should say.

But I do need to pick this teeny, tiny little bone with him before I can let it go.

By Mathew Schwartz on Unsplash

I’ve stayed in my lane as far as communities on Vocal are concerned. Most of my content is true crime or dark, morbid events. I noticed that the Criminal community rarely got a Top Story selection.

But writing in this genre has become harder than it used to be. Constant heartbreak and dread. Death. Hurt. Pain.

If you read my content regularly, you may have noticed I’ve typed my way into a couple of other communities. (Now, when I write true crime, I choose lighter stories.)

Don’t get me wrong: I am still a true crime junkie. But my writing about murder and terrible, horrible, no good people constantly (for years) isn’t exactly great for the nervous system.

I noticed some Communities were worse off for a Top Story than the Criminal community. It had been months or years in some of the genres.

I joined Vocal in ‘21 and earned a few Top Story honors along the way. Then, I realized it’s been years since any of my stories have been selected for “Top story” honors, even though my writing has greatly improved.

All of this got me thinking.

I'm no Stephen King, but dang it, why are my stories getting no recognition (from Vocal)? Why are some communities lacking a Top Story honor?

By Bruno Guerrero on Unsplash

Are the Vocal team haters who stick to the communities they like? Is there a system glitch? What the fudge popsicle?

Before I knew it, my brain concocted a funny story about it. I was proud.

The Case of the Missing Top Story” was its title.

I wrote it, rewrote it, edited it.

Then rewrote it again. It had mystery, suspense, and most importantly, solved my own conspiracy theory. Yeah, call me Sherlock Holmes.

By huan yu on Unsplash

Well, until Justin came along.

I started to doubt myself again. Should I publish the story? I did not want the story to be misconstrued by anyone, especially the Vocal staff. And, honestly, I wasn't 100% sure anyone else would read it.

(Not that it would be the first time).

Two weeks pass. The story sat in my docs, waiting.

Enough is enough. The Delete button is at my service if I change my mind later.

I look at the story and ask myself, "What would Nike do?"

Just do it.

By Clay LeConey on Unsplash

I head to Vocal, confident enough to publish my story. But first, I'll read the new update from Justin @Vocal.

Reading the exciting updates, I felt a huge slap in my face when Justin revealed why some communities haven’t had a Top Story in a while. (But did not explain why Vocal ghosted me).

He answered the question that my entire story centered around.

Vocal is sorting through spammers, scammers, and AI in many categories, including Criminal, where most of my work is found. And so, Vocal has nulled Top Story selections in some categories.

Just like that, my story was gone.

By Louis Galvez on Unsplash

Thanks a lot, Justin.

I could always publish the story and pretend that I didn't read the announcement.

Nah. I’m not that type of girl.

But I am suspicious.

Very suspicious.

I’m just not sure what I am suspicious of.

I’m not saying I have another conspiracy in my mind stemming from the first one…But I’m not saying I don’t.

as a true crime writer, where else do you expect my brain to go when suddenly, Justin pops up with answers to questions in my head like he's part of Scooby Doo & the gang?

He could have been nice enough to wait one more day to publish his story. Has he never heard of getting cold feet and letting an article marinate in Drafts for a while? Geesh.

Rude.

By Etty Fidele on Unsplash

Big sigh.

I’m glad Justin answered the question regarding Top Stories that many of us had. And ecstatic for the other changes we’ll soon see. But damn it, did he have to solve the case before I had time to play detective?

CommunityVocal

About the Creator

Criminal Matters

The best of the worst true crime, history, strange and Unusual stories.

Graphic material. Intended for a mature audience ONLY.

Follow me @ facebook.com/criminalmatterspage

Reader insights

Outstanding

Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!

Top insights

  1. Compelling and original writing

    Creative use of language & vocab

  2. Easy to read and follow

    Well-structured & engaging content

  3. Excellent storytelling

    Original narrative & well developed characters

  1. Expert insights and opinions

    Arguments were carefully researched and presented

  2. Eye opening

    Niche topic & fresh perspectives

  3. Heartfelt and relatable

    The story invoked strong personal emotions

  4. Masterful proofreading

    Zero grammar & spelling mistakes

  5. On-point and relevant

    Writing reflected the title & theme

Add your insights

Comments (21)

Sign in to comment
  • Paul Aaron Domenick2 days ago

    Thank you for sharing this behind-the-scenes account. Well deserved.

  • Andrea Corwin 4 days ago

    Hah congrats on Leaderboard! Way to go!!

  • Rachel Robbins4 days ago

    Congratulations on Top Story and Leaderboard placement. But also on offering up such a refreshing, considered account of writing what is in your mind. ❤️

  • Tina D. Lopez5 days ago

    So this got a top story and another top story was by a person complaining about issues with Vocal..I am seeing a trend---vocal wants a shout out!! Congratulations.

  • Wooohooooo congratulations on your Leaderboard placement! 🎉💖🎊🎉💖🎊

  • Mariann Carroll6 days ago

    Congratulations on Top Story, I am sure you made Justin's day with this one. I love how you pour your heart out in this story !!

  • Belle6 days ago

    Congrats on top story and thank you for sharing this funny and disappointing happening with us!! ~ waiting for Justin to enter the chat 😂 ~

  • Lol, Justin has no chill. I'm happy you got a Top Story for this one though hehehe. Congratulations! 🎉💖🎊🎉💖🎊 Although the Criminal community doesn't get Top Stories as much as the other communities, I realised that they get the most external reads. My top 10 most read pieces are from Criminal

  • Tiffany Gordon8 days ago

    🩷

  • Sid Aaron Hirji8 days ago

    haha funny story and a top story too

  • Colleen Walters8 days ago

    And just like that she got a Top Story! This is quite entertaining and worth the accolades. "But I am suspicious. Very suspicious. I’m just not sure what I am suspicious of." 😝 I love it!! I'm not sure what they look for in a Top Story, but I do know it's not "safe" to let a 10 yr old browse through them...😵‍💫 Great job on this! 🤩😊

  • I really loved this piece. It was funny, engaging, and informational. Well done. Not hard to see why you finally got a Top Story!

  • You got a Top Story, something I will never get from Hustin or Vocal

  • Marilyn Glover8 days ago

    Excellent top story; congratulations❣

  • Sara Wilson8 days ago

    I love that this won a top story lol congrats! 👏

  • Good one! Congratulations on your top story about your top story!

  • This actually made my morning lol I loved the way Justin’s announcement came like a A-Bomb for the reason some categories are essentially banned from getting a Top Story

  • Raine Fielder8 days ago

    The fact that this got top story, lol love that

  • hahaha, this was completely entertaining and still thorough enough to cover the facts...I for one am glad you dared the dread and won. Maybe we should be reading your drafts to see what other changes are coming...hahaha (just another conspiracy theorist) CONGRATS on getting top story. I have subscribed and look forward to seeing your name more often

  • Andrea Corwin 10 days ago

    Hahaha. JUSTIN, this should be a Top Story. Yes Vocal! Well done and go ahead call ‘em out. No guts, no glory. 👏😍

Find us on social media

Miscellaneous links

  • Explore
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Support

© 2026 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.