Dear John,
a Harper Lewis rogue challenge

Update here, comments closed on this post to prevent an organizational nightmare.
Spring is in the air, so let’s focus on love letters (kind of)—specifically, Dear John letters. Have you ever written one? Received one? Here’s your chance.
No, I don’t want anything from real life; you have to adhere to my premise, which is that you are in a relationship with your favorite literary character, and one of you wants to move on. Write a Dear John letter to or from your favorite literary character, totally up to you to decide who’s the dumper and who’s the dumpee. For extra special bonus, you may respond to any entry in addition to writing your own.
Example: I write a Dear John letter to (or from) Atticus Finch. Someone reads it and assumes the role of letter recipient, and they respond to it.
Sounds fun, right? Better than an ode to last year’s Easter bonnet or a villanelle of regret (fuck you, whoever came up with that widening gyre into Dante’s deepest pits, still haven’t recovered from all that godawful repetitive whining rhyme), in my humble opinion.
Unlimited haikus and limericks are one thing. Unlimited Dear John letters are quite another, unless you’re emulating Marty Maraschino from Grease (see one-woman USO), so let’s limit this to two entries of your choosing, whether that’s two letters of origination of relationship termination, two responses, or one of each*. I suppose you can respond to your own, but if you choose that option, bring your A-game to back up that ego, or you may find yourself in a marshmallow situation—impaled then held over the fire to be roasted.
While April Fool’s Day would be the ideal closing date, that’s one day after my late father’s birthday, so we’ll let this run for 30 days. Tax returns and Dear John letters on the same day. Hell, let’s throw a twist and allow Dear Johns to the IRS as well.
RHYME JUNKY WARNING:
End rhyme is tired, trite, and done to fucking death, so don’t do it here, no ABAB or ABBA rhyme schemes—that’s what they are: schemes. I’ll report your unclaimed rhymes to the IRS, perhaps add a flag for evading other literary devices while I’m at it.
Any community you want is fine with me, but if it’s in poetry, it better be an actual poem instead of some silly rhyme. Too many creators treat end rhyme as the end-all be-all of poetry, and far too many expect it to carry weight it can’t support, like making a toddler bring the double-bagged sack full of canned goods in from the car. No child labor allowed here.
Maybe I’ll write a Dear John letter to end rhyme (of course, I would need to time travel back to 1988, when there was a relationship to speak of). In case I haven’t made myself clear, don’t try to fake content with shiny terminal sounds; it doesn’t fool me. No willy-nilly, mamby-pamby, thoughtless rhyme allowed. If rhyme is present, it has to earn its keep.
All of that said, let’s break some hearts or hang characters out to dry, any approach you want, any tone. Maybe someone will break up with Dracula or Lady Macbeth. Have fun!
Prizes are still developing, not sure what kind of madness would be the best reward for this, but I have faith that it will come to me.
I forgot to mention that you should drop a link to your entries in the comments (boosting my leaderboard chances and giving me a one-stop shop to pick them up from).
Kendall has opened by setting the bar high:
And just for funsies:
Come play in my sandbox!
*those who read footnotes may submit as many entries as they want, and all will be considered. Rules are made to be broken 💖
About the Creator
Harper Lewis
I'm a subversive weirdo nerd witch who loves rocks. Intrusive rhyme bothers me. Some of my fiction may have provoked divorce proceedings in another state.😈
My words are mine. Suggest ai use and get eviscerated.
MA English literature, CofC
Reader insights
Outstanding
Excellent work. Looking forward to reading more!
Top insights
Easy to read and follow
Well-structured & engaging content
Eye opening
Niche topic & fresh perspectives
Heartfelt and relatable
The story invoked strong personal emotions
On-point and relevant
Writing reflected the title & theme



Comments (18)